Jack Young Counterfeit Coin 1796 S-93

By Jack D. Young, Early American Coppers (EAC) ……
 

This latest installment in the continuing summary of deceptive struck counterfeits documented to date centers around this 1796 “S-93” Large Cent; as in previous articles in this series, I have included a one-page attribution guide to aid in the identification of any that are still out there. Of the documented examples of this variety, one was certified by a TPG (the “discovery” example), another was caught in a submission to another TPG, and the genuine source by yet another…

* * *

Source coin for 1796 S-93 Large Cent counterfeits. Images courtesy Jack D. Young

Well-documented source example. All images courtesy Jack D. Young unless otherwise noted

This “variety” was first known from a single example discovered on the internet by a fellow EAC member back in 2015 (Penny-Wise</strong> January 2016 article); from review of the on-line images, and aided by the discovery of another example submitted to a top TPG days later the two were called fakes.

Kevin's "Discovery" example # 4. Images courtesy Jack D. Young

Kevin’s “Discovery” example # 4

"Discovery" example # 4 TPG Submission example # 5 (Dec 2015, not certified). Images courtesy Jack D. Young

Obverse, “Discovery” example #4 (L); TPG Submission example #5 – December 2015, not certified (R)

"Discovery" example # 4 TPG Submission example # 5 (Dec 2015, not certified). Images courtesy Jack D. Young

Reverse, “Discovery” example #4 (L); TPG Submission example # 5 – December 2015, not certified (R)

An interesting point to note in this comparison is that the “discovery” coin carries the same main sister marks of the second example on the right, but there are unique features between the two such as scratches, pits and other surface marks to indicate they are different examples, and certainly different than the original “source” coin.

“Source” example # 1 TPG “Genuine”. Images courtesy Jack D. Young

“Source” example # 1 TPG “Genuine”

Comparison of source example 1 with example 5. Images courtesy Jack D. Young

Obverse, Example #5 (L); Example #1 (R)

reverse comparison, examples 5 and 1. Images courtesy Jack D. Young

Reverse, Example #5 (L); Example #1 (R)

As in previous investigations, a time-line proved helpful in organizing the examples.

Timeline for the 1796 “S-93” Large Cent:

  1. September 2013 – TPG Genuine certified example sold in an auction house listing
  2. May 3, 2014 – Raw example listed in EAC sale-/unsold- same as #1
  3. November 21, 2014 – Raw example sold on the internet- same as #1
  4. December 10, 2015 – Example in a TPG VF30 Details holder sold on the internet
  5. December 15, 2015 – Raw example submitted to a TPG and called counterfeit

Example 3 raw. Images courtesy Jack D. Young, NGC

Example #3 raw (same as example #1)

This example is pedigreed to the Mass Historical Society and purportedly photographed by Breen, and recorded in Noyes; we should be concerned about losing a significant pedigreed example to the “process”- hopefully someone out there has given it a good home! In regards to finding more examples out there I would like to again quote my friend and fellow Dark Side participant Nick T.: “There are many marks on this one that should make it easy to spot a copy – easy as long as someone is looking!”

1796 S-93 counterfeit large cent attribution page 1

1796 S-93 counterfeit large cent attribution page 2

1796 S-93 counterfeit large cent attribution page 3

As always, the research continues to be a collaborative effort with many Early American Coppers (EAC) members, “Dark Side” members (our focused Facebook group of counterfeit researchers) and friends participating.

Best Regards,

–Jack D. Young, EAC 5050
 


NGC-Certified Large Cents Currently Available on eBay

eBay
 Pic  Title  Details
1842 Large Date Braided Hair Large Cent (F 15 BN) NGC Current Price: $19.0
# of Bids: 10
Ending: 2 days 11 hrs 46 mins
1847 Braided Hair Large Cent (F 12 BN) NGC Current Price: $18.5
# of Bids: 4
Ending: 3 days 11 hrs 45 mins
1845 N-11 NGC UNC Details Braided Hair Large Cent Coin 1c Current Price: $66.0
# of Bids: 9
Ending: 2 days 8 hrs 11 mins
1853 Braided Hair Large Cent, NGC VF35 Brown Current Price: $45.0
# of Bids: 0
Ending: 2 days 2 hrs 29 mins
1851 Braided Hair Large Cent AU / Almost Uncirculated 55 BN, NGC 1C DC Current Price: $142.0
# of Bids: 0
Ending: 5 days 3 hrs 8 mins
1806 (S-270) Draped Bust Large Cent (AG Details) NGC. Obverse scratched. Current Price: $20.5
# of Bids: 6
Ending: 1 day 11 hrs 34 mins
 View all items... (Powered by: WPeBayAds)  

LEAVE A REPLY

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.