HomeUS CoinsThree 1652 Colonial Coins, Three Remarkable Discoveries, $3.26 Million

Three 1652 Colonial Coins, Three Remarkable Discoveries, $3.26 Million

A Potato Field, Candy Tin, and Cabinet Hid America’s Earliest Coins

One emerged from a frozen potato field on Long Island. Another spent generations inside a candy tin in England. A third lay unidentified in an antique cabinet in the Netherlands.

All three were struck in Boston in 1652. All three belonged to the first series of coins produced in what would become the United States. And when these remarkable survivors eventually reached the auction block, they brought a combined $3,263,250.

The coins represent all three denominations of the original New England silver coinage: the threepence, sixpence, and shilling. Although they share a common origin, each followed a very different journey through nearly four centuries of history.

Together, their discoveries reveal something extraordinary about America’s earliest money. Even after generations of research and collecting, important colonial rarities can still emerge from the most unlikely places.

1652: When Boston Began Making America’s First Coins

In 1652, the Massachusetts Bay Colony faced a serious monetary problem.

Commerce depended heavily on foreign silver coins, many of which had become worn, underweight, or debased. Meanwhile, a chronic shortage of reliable currency complicated everyday trade.

Undated (1652) Massachusetts Bay Colony NE Shilling, Sixpence and Threepence
Undated (1652) Massachusetts Bay Colony NE Shilling, Sixpence and Threepence

Rather than continue relying entirely on foreign money, colonial leaders took an extraordinary step.

On May 27, 1652, the Massachusetts General Court authorized a mint in Boston. Officials selected silversmith John Hull as mintmaster, with Robert Sanderson serving as his partner.

Their assignment was straightforward: turn silver into dependable coins for local commerce.

However, Hull and Sanderson were silversmiths, not experienced coin makers. Instead of producing elaborately engraved coins, they relied on techniques familiar from their trade.

Workers prepared small silver blanks, or planchets, and struck them with simple punches.

One punch carried the initials NE, representing New England. A second indicated the denomination in Roman numerals.

The colony authorized three denominations:

  • Threepence: III, worth three pence.
  • Sixpence: VI, worth six pence.
  • Shilling: XII, worth 12 pence.

These plain silver pieces became the first coinage struck in England’s North American colonies.

Yet their simplicity created a problem.

With broad, undecorated surfaces and no protective border, the coins offered little protection against clipping. Someone could remove silver from an edge and attempt to pass the reduced coin at full value.

Consequently, the General Court ordered a more elaborate design in October 1652. The replacement coinage incorporated a tree, inscriptions, and protective borders.

The original NE series had an exceptionally short production life. Its mintages remain unknown, and surviving specimens rank among the great rarities of colonial American numismatics.

A Frozen Potato Field Reveals a 1652 New England Sixpence

In February 1990, Lillian Rade and her husband, Ron, were searching a frozen potato field in East Hampton, New York, with metal detectors.

Lillian uncovered a small silver coin.

At first, its importance was anything but obvious. The irregular piece carried unfamiliar markings and showed the effects of a long and difficult history.

Further investigation eventually identified it as a genuine 1652 New England sixpence, one of fewer than 10 generally recognized survivors.

1652 SixPENCE New England -- Damage or Tooling -- PCGS Genuine. VF Details. Noe 1-A | Image by Heritage Auctions showing the Revere in the holder
1652 SixPENCE New England — Damage or Tooling — PCGS Genuine. VF Details. Noe 1-A | Image by Heritage Auctions showing the Revere in the holder Sept 2019

The discovery attracted national attention. It even appeared in Ripley’s Believe It or Not! in 1991.

There was a historical connection to the location, too. Eastern Long Island maintained close commercial and cultural relationships with New England during the colonial period. A Massachusetts silver coin finding its way into that region was entirely plausible.

Nevertheless, how this particular sixpence reached the potato field remains unknown.

From $35,200 to $431,250

On November 21, 1991, Sotheby’s auctioned the sixpence for $35,200.

Stack’s acquired the coin and later placed it privately with collector John “Jack” Royse.

More than two decades after its discovery, the piece returned to auction.

On November 16, 2012, Stack’s Bowers Galleries sold the famous potato-field sixpence for $431,250, including the buyer’s premium.

PCGS had certified it as VF Details, Damage or Tooling. A prominent diagonal scratch crossed much of the obverse.

Yet those imperfections did not diminish the coin’s historical appeal.

The sixpence demonstrated that an extraordinary rarity need not survive in pristine condition to command an extraordinary price.

Coin specifications: Undated (1652) NE Sixpence; Noe 1-A, W-10; silver; 31.8 grains; PCGS VF Details, Damage or Tooling.

A Candy Tin in England Holds the Finest 1652 NE Shilling

More than three decades after the Long Island discovery, another remarkable example of the original NE coinage surfaced across the Atlantic.

In 2021, an old confectionery tin came to light at Bywell Hall, the Beaumont family’s historic home in Northumberland, England.

The tin contained an assortment of coins and medals. Among them were a Massachusetts Pine Tree shilling, two pewter Continental Currency dollars dated 1776, and a Libertas Americana medal.

However, one piece stood apart.

It was an undated 1652 New England shilling.

Undated (1652) NE Shilling. Noe 3-B, Salmon 3-C, W-80. Rarity-7. MS-61 (NGC)
Undated (1652) NE Shilling. Noe 3-B, Salmon 3-C, W-80. Rarity-7. MS-61 (NGC)

Art adviser Wentworth “Wenty” Beaumont brought the collection to London auction house Morton & Eden, where specialists recognized the shilling’s exceptional importance.

Unlike most surviving NE shillings, this example retained remarkable original surface texture and showed no circulation wear.

NGC certified the Noe 3-B variety as MS-61. At the time, it was the only NE shilling of any variety that either major grading service had certified in Mint State.

A Possible Connection to a 17th-Century Settler

The Beaumont family’s American connections added another layer to the discovery.

One ancestor, William Wentworth (1616–1697), settled in New England during the 1630s. His descendants became prominent in colonial New Hampshire.

Auction researchers suggested that William Wentworth might have acquired the shilling when it was new.

That possibility offers a fascinating explanation for the coin’s preservation. However, no surviving documentation establishes when it entered the family’s possession.

The shilling made international news when Morton & Eden sold it on November 26, 2021, for £264,000, approximately $351,912 at the time.

Then, on November 1, 2022, the same coin appeared in Stack’s Bowers Galleries’ Winter Auction.

It realized $312,000.

Coin specifications: Undated (1652) NE Shilling; Noe 3-B, Salmon 3-C, W-80; silver; 72.2 grains; NGC MS-61.

The $2.52 Million Threepence Hidden in an Antique Cabinet

The most financially significant discovery of the three involved the smallest denomination.

For generations, collectors regarded the 1652 New England threepence as one of the most elusive coins in American numismatics.

William Sumner Appleton owned an example that eventually entered the Massachusetts Historical Society’s collection. The coin remains there today.

Yale University once possessed another specimen. However, it disappeared before the middle of the 20th century and has never resurfaced.

Consequently, no privately available example of the Threepence had been known for more than a century.

That changed because of a discovery in the Netherlands.

Undated (1652) NE Threepence. Noe 1-A, Salmon 1-A, W-1. Rarity-8. EF-45 (PCGS). CMQ-X.
Undated (1652) NE Threepence. Noe 1-A, Salmon 1-A, W-1. Rarity-8. EF-45 (PCGS). CMQ-X.

Around 2016, a collector encountered a small group of early American coins in an antique cabinet.

Among them was an unidentified silver piece bearing the initials NE and the denomination III.

The coin’s true identity did not emerge until 2020.

Researchers subsequently undertook extensive authentication work, including metallurgical examination and comparisons with the Massachusetts Historical Society specimen.

PCGS certified the threepence as EF-45 in 2024.

Remarkably, it was sharper and better preserved than the holed example held by the historical society.

Did the Coin Travel to Europe Through the Adams Family?

The Threepence also carried a tantalizing historical clue.

According to Stack’s Bowers, the coin originally rested in a now-lost pasteboard box bearing an old handwritten inscription that associated it with Boston’s Quincy family and a December 1798 date.

That detail immediately attracted attention.

Abigail Adams, wife of President John Adams, belonged to the Quincy family. Moreover, the family’s ancestry included a connection to John Hull, the Boston mintmaster responsible for the 1652 coinage.

There was another intriguing link.

In October 1781, while serving as an American diplomat in Europe, John Adams asked Abigail to obtain several old New England shillings. English collector Thomas Brand Hollis had expressed interest in acquiring the historic coinage.

Adams repeated his request in January 1782.

The correspondence demonstrates that collectors already treasured NE silver coins during the Revolutionary era.

Could the newly discovered Threepence have reached Europe through the same network of collectors and family connections?

Possibly. However, the surviving evidence does not establish that route, and the coin’s complete early ownership history remains unresolved.

A Historic $2.52 Million Auction Result

On November 18, 2024, Stack’s Bowers Galleries offered the newly authenticated Threepence in its November Showcase Auction.

Bidders competed for an opportunity that collectors had effectively lacked for generations: ownership of a genuine NE Threepence.

The final price reached $2,520,000, including the buyer’s premium.

At the time, the result established a record for American coinage struck before the Revolution.

The price was particularly remarkable considering the coin’s modest physical dimensions.

It weighed just 17 grains, approximately 1.1 grams, and measured 20.2 by 21.3 millimeters.

Almost four centuries after its creation, one of colonial America’s smallest coins had become one of its most valuable numismatic treasures.

Coin specifications: Undated (1652) NE Threepence; Noe 1-A, Salmon 1-A, W-1; silver; 17.0 grains; PCGS EF-45, CMQ-X.

Three Extraordinary Discoveries, One American Beginning

The sixpence spent centuries beneath the soil of Long Island. The shilling survived in a family collection in northern England. The threepence traveled an uncertain path that eventually led to an antique cabinet in the Netherlands.

Their combined documented auction results reached $3,263,250, although the sales took place in different years and do not represent a current valuation of the three coins.

More importantly, these discoveries preserve direct connections to an extraordinary moment in American history.

In 1652, nearly 125 years before the Declaration of Independence, the Massachusetts Bay Colony established a mint and began producing its own silver money.

Hull and Sanderson could scarcely have imagined what their simple punches would eventually represent.

Yet the coins they created became the beginning of a tradition that continued through the colonial era, the founding of the United States Mint in 1792, and the enormous variety of American coinage produced since.

And perhaps the most remarkable part of their story is that, after nearly 375 years, collectors are still discovering them.

Do you have any tips or insights to add on this topic?
Share your knowledge in the comments! ......

CoinWeek
CoinWeek
Coinweek is the top independent online media source for rare coin and currency news, with analysis and information contributed by leading experts across the numismatic spectrum.

Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Search CoinWeek

Social Media

Stacks Bowers December Auction

Heritage Auctions

R and I Coins

Northern Nevada Rare Coins