In a landmark verdict delivered on Friday, July 18, 2025, a 12-person jury found Douglas Smith of McCloud, California, guilty of two counts of first-degree murder in connection with the brutal robbery and double homicide that occurred at “The Coin Shop” in downtown Cheyenne, Wyoming, nearly a decade ago.
The tragic event took place in 2015, when Dwight Brockman, the owner of The Coin Shop, and George Manley were fatally shot during a robbery that stunned the numismatic community and local residents. In the initial stages of the investigation, the Numismatic Crime Information Center (NCIC) reached out and assisted the Cheyenne Police Department, utilizing the organization’s specialized intelligence network, investigative resources, and nationwide alerts.
After years of persistence and collaboration among multiple agencies, a breakthrough occurred. On June 25, 2024, Douglas Smith was arrested on a warrant alleging two counts of first-degree murder. Now, just days shy of the 10th anniversary of the murders, justice has been served.
“The successful resolution of this case highlights not only the unwavering commitment of the Cheyenne Police Department and supporting agencies but also the unique value that NCIC provides in these complex investigations,” said Doug Davis, Founder and President of NCIC. “Crimes involving rare coins and precious metals require a highly specialized understanding of the market, the players, and how stolen items move. Our organization exists to provide that expertise.”
The NCIC continues to play a pivotal role in helping victims and law enforcement navigate the complexities of numismatic crimes, offering tools such as a centralized database, investigative bulletins, and real-time alerts. Their efforts have led to numerous recoveries of stolen assets and the apprehension of suspects in cases that otherwise might remain unsolved.
“This case is a stark reminder of the stakes involved in numismatic crimes,” Davis continued. “We honor the memory of Dwight Brockman and George Manley by reaffirming our mission to support justice and protect the numismatic community.”
For more information, to report a numismatic crime, or to access resources, visit Numismatic Crime Information Center.
