The 2021 Silver Eagle Redesign That Ended a 35-Year Tradition
In 2021, the United States Mint made American Silver Eagle history. For the first time since the series began in 1986, collectors could purchase proof Silver Eagles featuring two different reverse designs in the same year.
One coin brought a 35-year tradition to a close. The other introduced a new chapter in America’s most popular silver bullion coin series.
Together, the 2021-W Type 1 and Type 2 Proof American Silver Eagles capture that remarkable transition. This two-coin pairing features both designs in traditional proof finish, with each coin earning the Numismatic Guaranty Company (NGC) grade of PF70 Ultra Cameo.

Note: This set is also the featured CoinWeek Giveaway # 668 prize to be awarded Nov 28th, 2026
The End of the Original Silver Eagle Design
When the American Silver Eagle debuted in 1986, the Mint combined two distinctive pieces of American coinage artistry.
The obverse revived Adolph A. Weinman’s celebrated Walking Liberty design, which originally appeared on the half dollar from 1916 through 1947.
Meanwhile, the reverse featured an entirely new creation from U.S. Mint engraver John Mercanti. His heraldic eagle carried a shield across its breast, an olive branch in one talon, and arrows in the other. Thirteen stars completed the patriotic composition.
For 35 years, Mercanti’s design remained a familiar feature of the American Silver Eagle.
However, the Mint planned a major redesign for the program’s 35th anniversary in 2021.
Before introducing the new artwork, it gave Mercanti’s eagle one final appearance on the regular proof issue.
On February 11, 2021, the Mint released the 2021-W Type 1 Proof Silver Eagle, preserving the original reverse design for its final year.
A New Eagle Takes Flight in July 2021
Five months later, collectors encountered a dramatically different Silver Eagle.
On July 20, the Mint launched the 2021-W Type 2 Proof Silver Eagle, introducing a reverse by artist Emily Damstra.
Instead of the traditional heraldic composition, Damstra depicted a bald eagle approaching a landing. Its wings stretch outward as it carries an oak branch toward a possible nesting site. Mint medallic artist Michael Gaudioso sculpted the design.
The changes extended beyond the reverse.
The Mint also refreshed Weinman’s Walking Liberty obverse, bringing its details closer to the artist’s original work. In addition, the updated coin includes Weinman’s distinctive AW monogram.
Another innovation appears along the edge. The Type 2 Silver Eagle introduced a variation in its reeding to help discourage counterfeiting.
Consequently, the 2021-W proof coins offer collectors more than two different eagle designs. They document a significant artistic and technical transformation within the series.
Two Standard Proofs, Not the Mint’s Reverse Proof Set
An important distinction separates this pairing from another famous 2021 Silver Eagle release.
Both coins in this matched Type 1 and Type 2 collection feature the traditional proof finish, with deeply mirrored fields and heavily frosted design elements. Furthermore, both carry the W mintmark of the West Point Mint.
Collectors and dealers assembled these individually issued standard proofs into matching two-coin collections.

By contrast, the U.S. Mint released its official American Eagle Silver Reverse Proof Two-Coin Designer Set on September 13, 2021.
That separate product contained a West Point Type 1 and a San Francisco Type 2. Both featured reverse proof finishes, with frosted fields and mirrored design elements. The Mint limited production to 125,000 sets.
Therefore, the two 2021-W standard proofs represent a distinctly different collectible pairing.
Perfect NGC PF70 Ultra Cameo Examples
The featured coins also share NGC’s highest numerical proof grade: PF70 Ultra Cameo (PF70UC).
NGC assigns the 70 grade to coins that show no post-production imperfections under five-power magnification. Meanwhile, its Ultra Cameo designation recognizes exceptional contrast between the deeply mirrored fields and heavily frosted devices.
Each coin contains one troy ounce of .999 fine silver, measures 40.6 millimeters in diameter, and carries a one-dollar legal tender denomination.
Together, the two coins contain two troy ounces of pure silver.
Yet their greatest appeal extends beyond silver content or certified condition.
The Type 1 preserves the conclusion of a design collectors recognized for more than three decades. The Type 2 celebrates the beginning of the modern Silver Eagle era.
Few dates in the American Silver Eagle series offer collectors such a clear before-and-after moment.
With both 2021-W designs together in perfect proof grades, this two-coin collection preserves one of the most important transitions in modern American numismatics.




