HomeModern CoinsWatch: CoinWeek Goes Bust Buying $200 Graded Silver Coin "Mystery Box"

Watch: CoinWeek Goes Bust Buying $200 Graded Silver Coin “Mystery Box”

What happens when a knowledgable numismatist drops $200 on a graded silver coin “mystery box” on eBay?

You’re about to find out.

CoinWeek editor Charles Morgan couldn’t resist the opportunity to take a shot at a 20-coin lot of NGC- and PCGS-graded silver coins, containing what the seller promised would be three silver dimes, 15 silver quarters, and two silver half dollars (with some of the coins being in Mint State).

At $199.90 for the box, he’d have to average $10 a coin to break even.

Did he do it? Not even close – which goes to show that you should always temper your expectations when you’re buying blind coin lots. Sometimes you win. Sometimes you lose.

Sometimes you go bust!

* * *

Copyright ©2019 CoinWeek, LLC

More news and videos about coin collecting at CoinWeek.com.

Related Articles


  1. Interesting video, enjoyed your commentary. The lot could best be described of interest only to a beginner or novice (the kind of casual collector who buys the stuff advertised in the glossy inserts found in Sunday papers). Would like to see if the seller would accept a return. Most eBay sellers loathe negative feedback and will go out of their way to avoid it. A few years ago I purchased a number of assorted PCGS slabbed statehood quarters at rock bottom prices (many of the slabs were scratched) and still wonder why I bothered. Benjamin Franklin said it best: A bargain is something you buy but didn’t really want.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.